Challah dough calculator
Braided challah on water, oil, honey and eggs, with the strand weights for the braid.
Total hydration counts the water inside the eggs, milk and butter.
Challah in the classic tradition: a braided loaf enriched with eggs, oil and honey — and defined as much by what it lacks: no milk, no butter. King Arthur’s formula is the anchor: water-based, egg-rich, glossy under its egg wash.
How it works
Water, oil, honey — on purpose
The liquid is 34% water; the fat is 15% oil; the sweetener is 12.5% honey. Eggs run 20% plus 3.5% yolks. The dairy-free build is deliberate: traditional challah accompanies meals where dairy is excluded. The oil-based crumb is springy, fine and faintly sweet.
Dough and braid
With 1.8% salt and 2.4% instant yeast the schedule runs about two hours of bulk and up to ninety minutes of proof. Divide the ~950 g of dough into equal strands — three for the classic braid, more if you are showing off — roll them even, and braid snug but not tight; the proof needs room.
The double egg wash
Brush the risen braid with the reserved egg white beaten with a little water, just before baking — the deep mahogany gloss is challah’s signature. Bake at ~190 °C until richly browned; tent with foil if the braid ridges darken early.
Sources & methodology
Every percentage in this calculator traces to the published sources below — nothing is invented. Where respected sources disagree, the default sits inside the documented range.
- King Arthur — Classic Challah — The classic water challah: 34% water, 15% oil, 12.5% honey, eggs plus a yolk — the trio that defines the style.
- Smitten Kitchen — best challah — The Joan Nathan lineage cross-checks the dairy-free water-and-oil build — sweetened with sugar rather than honey.
FAQ
Is Polish chałka the same thing?
Same braid, different family: the Polish bakery chałka is typically a milk-and-butter sweet loaf, closer to a brioche-lite. Traditional Jewish challah is water-and-oil, as here. If you grew up on Polish chałka, expect this to be less buttery and more springy.
Honey or sugar?
Respected versions use both — Joan Nathan’s famous recipe (via Smitten Kitchen) runs sugar at a similar level. Honey browns faster and reads more aromatic; swap gram for gram if you prefer sugar.
Why did my braid blur together?
Overproofed or braided too loose with strands too soft. Braid when the strands still hold a firm line, and bake at the “slow poke recovery” stage — the oven spring will fill the braid without erasing it.
More from Buns & enriched breads
Brioche dough calculator
Hamelman's brioche: 50% butter and 50% eggs against the flour, chilled overnight.
Hydration 56% · 500 g
Bagel dough calculator
Reinhart's bagels: 56% hydration, malt, a night in the fridge and a boil before baking.
Hydration 56% · 16 × 100 g
Soft pretzel dough calculator
Bavarian Laugenbrezeln: a stiff 52% dough with malt and butter, dipped in lye.
Hydration 52% · 8 × 100 g
Kaiser roll dough calculator
Kaiser rolls with malt, egg and an overnight preferment, stamped and baked hot.
Hydration 69% · 6 × 125 g
Bun and enriched dough calculators12 calculators